%0 Journal Article %J Transgenic Res. %D 2016 %T Quality of laboratory studies assessing effects of Bt-proteins on non-target organisms: minimal criteria for acceptability %A Adinda De Schrijver %A Y. Devos %A P. De Clercq %A A. Gathmann %A J. Romeis %K Bt-maize %K Cry34/ 35Ab1 %K DAS-59122-7 %K environmental risk assessment %K Non-target effects %X

The potential risks that genetically modified plants may pose to non-target organisms and the ecosystem services they contribute to are assessed as part of pre-market risk assessments. This paper reviews the early tier studies testing the hypothesis whether exposure to plant-produced Cry34/35Ab1 proteins as a result of cultivation of maize 59122 is harmful to valued non-target organisms, in particular Arthropoda and Annelida. The available studies were assessed for their scientific quality by considering a set of criteria determining their relevance and reliability. As a case-study, this exercise revealed that when not all quality criteria are met, weighing the robustness of the study and its relevance for risk assessment is not obvious. Applying a worst-case expected environmental concentration of bioactive toxins equivalent to that present in the transgenic crop, confirming exposure of the test species to the test substance, and the use of a negative control were identified as minimum criteria to be met to guarantee sufficiently reliable data. This exercise stresses the importance of conducting studies meeting certain quality standards as this minimises the probability of erroneous or inconclusive results and increases confidence in the results and adds certainty to the conclusions drawn.

%B Transgenic Res. %V 25 %P 395-411 %G eng %N 4 %1 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26980555?dopt=Abstract %R 10.1007/s11248-016-9950-8